اقرأ باسم ربك الذي خلق

Sawaal Puche


Juveria said...

Assalaamu alaikum. Jazak Allah khair is panel ko open karne ke liye. Mera sawaal ye hai ki Aurto ki aksariyat Jahannam me kyu hai?

Nuzhat ny said...

‘ wallahu wa Rasool alam “ kehna kaisa hae ? Kuch log “ wallahu alam “ nahi kehkar “ wallahu wa rasool alam “ kehte hain aur jab unse kaha jaata k aisa nahi kehna chahiyeh kyun ki Rasool (SAW) hamare saat zinda nahi hae tho volog kehte hain k hadith me Sahabaon ne kaha hae “ Allah aur uske rasool behtar jaante hain “ . Lekin tab huzoor zinda the aur unke saamne the isilye kaha jaata tha . Aise log ko kaise samjhayain ?

Faisal Khan said...

@Juveria: wa alaykum assalaam. kindly is article ko chq kare (hindi version bhi attached h): https://www.iqrakitab.com/2019/02/jahannam-me-aurato-ki-aksariyat-kyu.html

Faisal Khan said...

@Nuzhat: Ham sirf Allahu alam kahne ko sahih samajhte kyuki hadees me hame yahi milta hai ki jab koi sawaal Rasoolullah ﷺ kisi sahabi se puchte the toh uske jawab me sahaba e karaam 'wallahu wa rasool alam' kahte the lekin hame ye kahi bhi nahi ki iske alawa kisi sahabi ne wallahu wa rasool alam kaha ho. Agar aesa ho to fir daleel pesh kiya jaaye in shaa Allah ham dobara fikr karne ko tayaar hai.

Aur ham Allahu alam kahte hai,hamari dalail ye hai:

۩ Narrated `Abdullah:

It is a sign of having knowledge that, when you do not know something, you say: 'Allah knows better.' Allah said to his Prophet: 'Say: No wage do I ask of you for this (Qur'an), nor am I one of the pretenders (a person who pretends things which do not exist)' (38.86) [Sahih al bukhari, 4822].

۩ Narrated `Aisha:

We used to salt some of the meat of sacrifice and present it to the Prophet (ﷺ) at Medina. Once he said, "Do not eat (of that meat) for more than three days." That was not a final order, but (that year) he wanted us to feed of it to others, Allah knows better. [Sahih al bukhari, 5570].

Hame daleel ki roshni me aur hikmat ke sath unhe samajhana hai. Baaki ham sirf paigaam pohcha sakte h, hidayat dene ke kaam Allah ka hai.

Wa Allaho alam.

Unknown said...

Assalamualaikum
Can Muslim women and muslim female students participate in protest rallies etc

Faisal Khan said...

@Anonymous (16 Jan)

Wa alaykum assalaam warahmatullah.

Yes. They can participate in protest rallies, with fulling some condition discussed here: https://www.islamweb.net/en/fatwa/242911/ruling-on-protests-to-demand-rights-for-muslim-minority

Abubakar said...

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barkatahu Mera sawaal hai kya koi ahadees hame milti hai kya jisme Nabi e Akram (saw) ne Kaha ilm hasil Karna sirf aalim ya mufti se???

Faisal Khan said...

@AbuBakar

wa alaykum assalaam warahmatullahi wabarakatuhu..

Mere ilm me aesi koi hadees nahi hai. Ha isse related ek Quran ki ayat hai jo kahti hai ki Agar apko ilm na ho toh unse pucho jinhe ilm ho. (16:43).

Lekin iska matlab ye nahi hai ki sirf unse hame ilm lena hai jo Mufti ya Ulema hai, Ham unse bhi ilm le sakte hai jinko sirf ek ayat hi ka ilm ho kyuki Rasoolullah ﷺ ne farmaya hai ki, 'Pahuchado Meri Taraf Se Wo Kyu Na Ek Ayat Hi Ho.' (Sahih al Bukhaari, 3461)

Is ayat ke mutallik Shaykh ibn Uthaymeen r.h. kahte hai,

“Jab ek shaks us chiz ki samajh rakhta hai jis ke taraf wo logo ko bula raha hai to isse koi fark nahi padta ke wo bada ya mashhoor aalim ho ya Deen ka sachha taalib e ilm ho ya ek aam sa aadmi ho jise kuch ilm ho us masle me jo sawal pucha ja raha hai.
RasoolAllah ﷺ ne farmaya hai, "Pohcha do meri taraf se wo kyu na ek ayat hi ho", aur unhone ne ye shart nahi rakhi ke us daaiyah (logo ko deen ki taraf bulane wale) ko Ilm ke aala darjeh par faiz hona chahiye, bas zaroori hai ke use us baat ka ilm ho jiski taraf wo bula raha hai. Lekin apne la-ilmi aur apne jazbaat ke bina par logo ko (deen ki taraf) bulane ki ijazat nahi hai.” End quote.

Fataawa ‘Ulama’ al-Balad al-Haraam, p. 329.

Mazeed ilm ke liye ye article check kare: https://www.iqrakitab.com/2019/01/deen-ki-baate-batane-ke-liye-certificate-ki-zarurat-nahi-hoti.html